Monday, December 31, 2007

Loyalty for financial products

The festive season has given me a little time to start reading some blogs again and spend a little time thinking and writing. A couple of the interesting posts I came across relate closely to some of the research I have recently been doing around financial services and the value of financial products and their associated customer services.

To start with there were several discussions around something that many of us have contact with around this time of year - the loyalty program. Love 'em or hate 'em, the loyalty program has introduced itself into every type of company that depends on repeat business. One of the longest running types, the frequent flyer programs run by airlines (e.g. BA, United) and alliances (e.g. Airmiles, Star Alliance) have traditionally been placed to encourage frequent travelers to always fly with the same airline. In the past the benefit to the customer of this was twofold: firstly to collect enough 'miles' to redeem for a free flight for pleasure; second, to gain status to receive upgrades and enhanced customer service. The cost of these programs could be assessed by the airlines and shown to provide the return of constant repeat business from customers.

As the post The declining value of loyalty plans on The Bankwatch blog highlights, the loyalty program experienced by many travelers is being perceived as much lower value than in the past. In the post, Colin states:

So stepping up a level, loyalty points and plans are only of value if the customer feels value.  Fewer are feeling that value nowadays, and those Banks who pay for those plans, should think about that.  I think the loyalty plan model is broken.

The implication is that airline loyalty programs are failing to meet customer expectations and therefore may not lead to the repeat business that is built into the business model. The question is whether there are things that financial services institutions do for their customers that actually reduce repeat business.

Colin's post was actually in reaction to Customer Experience Matters More Than Points In Building Loyalty on Forrester's Marketing Blog, which relays the experience of Shar Van Boskirk in traveling recently:

Except!  That I am really bothered by Linda's mantra "I don't care who you are or how much you travel."  Now the idea of a loyalty program is that you DEFINITELY care how much I travel and I've found that my fundamental weakness as a traveler is that I really want people to care who I am.

The loyalty program has degenerated from the ability to build status as a traveler to achieve enhanced customer service and rewards, to the one thing that may get you home on the same day you started traveling when the overbooked airline starts prioritizing the handout of the last remaining seats on the only flight that hasn't been canceled. This means that use of frequent flier benefits only reinforces in my mind how poorly an airline is operating since I'm only using the benefits to negate a failure on the airline's part. This is more of an 'anti-loyalty' program...

Does this relate to banking and financial services in general? As banks and other institutions realize that customer service is core to retaining gaining more market share, understand customer loyalty and attracting new customers is key, while avoiding reinforcing negative perceptions should not be overlooked.

An oversimplification is that much of the whole model of retail banking is built on repeat business and that banks can just assume it will happen: a bank account ties you to doing business with the bank. If I want the bank to hold my cash, I have to pay for their transactions to make a transfer. At least with my bank there is no explicit loyalty program, beyond them offering a reasonably competitive online banking service that doesn't annoy me every time I use it (i.e. being marginally better than other banks). As a standard customer if I want the equivalent of premium service I basically have to pay for it through additional charges, and traditionally its been hard to move bank accounts, so I'll not do it too often.

To a bank this may appear to make a lot of sense. In everyday operation there is little to differentiate me as a customer from almost every other customer that maintains a relationship with the bank; my salary is deposited into the account and sits there until I pay some bills and maybe move a little cash to a savings account - pretty much the same as every other professional person. Attempting to segment me based on this limited information does not help the bank offer me better services or do something that will help stop me moving to a new bank.

The best many institutions do is offer a basic form of loyalty bonus such as offering better rates of interest on a new savings account to current customers. Brokerage accounts can offer a sliding scale for charges based on volume or offering cheaper trades to buy into their investment products also offers a loyalty incentive.

Customer service remains the new frontier of financial services as it becomes easier for customers to find and move their money to new institutions. For financial services loyalty and repeat business still have some major stumbling blocks:

  • No aggregated view of a customer is available that the bank can use for managing my relationship and offering reasonable customer service when I call a branch or call center
  • Information is not shared between business units, preventing me easily signing up for new products online
  • A single / complete view of me as a customer is not available so that the bank can see whether I am actually a great customer owning multiple of their products (and therefore worth working harder to retain) or just a mediocre customer with a savings account
  • Based on limited information, segmenting customers for marketing new services and products is impossible
  • Credit agencies are often seen as the primary source of aggregated information about me. Does a FICO score really offer appropriate metrics for offering me appropriate products and strong customer service?

Many of the issues relate back to opening a new account with an institution. Only with an accurate view of a customer from that point of 'on-boarding' through the customer lifecycle can a true relationship be effectively managed. In my opinion many financial services institutions have a lot of work to do to get an accurate and unified view of their customers, let alone measure and use the metrics that really identify the customers worth concentrating on.


Anonymous said...


Great blog. It occurs to me that Airlines and Hotels need loyalty programs to learn things about their customers that Financial Services should better understand.

By this I mean that American Airlines knows that in response to certain promotions, I will purchase a ticket. They don't know what else I'll buy that same day unless I choose to book a rental car through their site. My bank, however, knows that I bought the ticket, that I stayed in a hotel, that I made a mortgage payment, and am saving money for three kids to go to University.

So the opportunity for Financial Services to leverage comprehansive information about me to deliver better customer service should allow them to eclipse the value of a loyalty program. Sure, I want free flights now and again but more importantly I want goo dcustomer service across all my financial services products. And, if you can discern what I like from what I've bought and that into which I've invested, then intelligently offer me the opportunity to buy more of what I like and invest more wisely, etc.

Financial services have so much information potentially available to them, but not yet crossing into the right silos to give them the chance to truly develop the kind of customer loyalty they want.

Again, great post!


Phil Ayres said...


You've hit upon some great points here. Your bank really does know a lot about you and rarely do they use it to serve you better or even offer you more personalized offers. Certainly they need to take a little care not to share your information in the process, though its hard to tell how limiting the GLB Act is in the US, compared to international privacy legislation. Another feature of a well designed compliance program, I'm sure.

In the meantime I'm sure that your bank will be very happy with your money until your kids hit college age though!

Thanks for the comment (when are you going to start blogging?)


Pawan Kumar Singh said...

Each individual has many dreams in life of having a home theatre system, a personal computer or a long holiday free from all tensions but for all these dreams to get fulfilled money is required and in case of penniless these dreams are shattered. But the good news is that these dreams can be real by opting for personal loans.